GET IT WRITE • ACADEMIC RESOURCE
Critical analysis: from description to evaluation
Practical academic guidance to support independent study and stronger editorial decisions.
Step 1
Define the central claim and why it matters to the assessment question.
Step 2
Compare at least two perspectives, distinguishing their theoretical assumptions and evidence bases.
Step 3
Evaluate sample characteristics, research design, validity, context and limitations.
Step 4
Explain whether disagreement arises from definitions, methods or different populations.
Step 5
End the section by linking that evaluation to your reasoned position.
